Help Looking for ppl to critique some song ideas/melodies i made

[justwannadip]

Hey guys, like the title says, just looking for someone to listen to some very rough melody ideas I made. I've never released or shown anyone these rlly and I'm gonna ctb soon, so i thought why not. Also pls give HONEST feedback or criticism, I'm not looking for fake support and encouragers, just ur actual reaction and thoughts. I promise u won't make me feel better or not ctb by saying 'omg this is so good ur so talented' if its not actually how u feel lmao. I'd much rather ur genuine opinion , don't worry I'm not sensitive to it. But ya, hope someone is open to this :) u can msg me ur discord or any other socials i can share audio files on - pretty sure I can't on here. Thanks

 

[justwannadip]

Ok just realized I can send audio files on here in private conversations so dm me if you'd like :)