Help Questioning the quality of a’s n

[bubbletea]

I've come across this article that talks about how important the quality of n must be for it to be painless.

Harvard anesthesiologist David Waisel told Mother Jones that even tiny contaminants in pentobarbital from a compounding pharmacy could "cause an inmate immense pain in his veins" which could be "compared to rubbing sandpaper on an open wound."

In April triple murderer Jose Villegas was executed using the current stock of pentobarbital. As it began to flow through his veins, he noted, "It does kind of burn," before gasping several times and falling silent

Redirect Notice

Has anyone tested the quality of a's n? How do we know for sure that it is pure enough to be painless?

 

[Nitromask]

Well, for one, it doesn't come from a compounding pharmacy like the stuff mentioned in the article. It's a premade veterinary solution. Also you're not going to be injecting it (I hope)

 

[bubbletea]

Well, for one, it doesn't come from a compounding pharmacy like the stuff mentioned in the article. It's a premade veterinary solution. Also you're not going to be injecting it (I hope)

I saw on one of the forums that the solution contained other compounds such as ethyl(?) not sure exactly but another user said that it could contribute to burning. Does anyone know what a's n solution is really composed of, it's purity, etc?

 

[Nitromask]

I saw on one of the forums that the solution contained other compounds such as ethyl(?) not sure exactly but another user said that it could contribute to burning. Does anyone know what a's n solution is really composed of, it's purity, etc?

I'm not sure what brand he uses, but here are the ingredients of a generic version I found. There's probably not much difference between the various brands, but I'm not sure:

Each mL contains: active ingredients: 390 mg pentobarbital sodium (barbituric acid derivative), 50 mg phenytoin sodium; inactive ingredients: 10% ethyl alcohol, 18% propylene glycol, 0.003688 mg rhodamine B, 2% benzyl alcohol (preservative), water for injection q.s. Sodium hydroxide and/or hydrochloric acid may be added to adjust pH.

 

[bubbletea]

Secret sedative: How Missouri uses pentobarbital in executions

Missouri will use two of its 34 vials of the sedative pentobarbital on Tuesday when it executes Marcellus Williams, who was convicted in the 1998 killing…

news.stlpublicradio.org

I'm not sure what brand he uses, but here are the ingredients of a generic version I found. There's probably not much difference between the various brands, but I'm not sure:

Each mL contains: active ingredients: 390 mg pentobarbital sodium (barbituric acid derivative), 50 mg phenytoin sodium; inactive ingredients: 10% ethyl alcohol, 18% propylene glycol, 0.003688 mg rhodamine B, 2% benzyl alcohol (preservative), water for injection q.s. Sodium hydroxide and/or hydrochloric acid may be added to adjust pH.

I'm wondering if the other ingredients may cause complications mentioned above in the article.

 

[Jamba]

I've come across this article that talks about how important the quality of n must be for it to be painless.

Harvard anesthesiologist David Waisel told Mother Jones that even tiny contaminants in pentobarbital from a compounding pharmacy could "cause an inmate immense pain in his veins" which could be "compared to rubbing sandpaper on an open wound."

In April triple murderer Jose Villegas was executed using the current stock of pentobarbital. As it began to flow through his veins, he noted, "It does kind of burn," before gasping several times and falling silent

Redirect Notice

Has anyone tested the quality of a's n? How do we know for sure that it is pure enough to be painless?

I think even if its a bit painful, it would not last for long as you would fall asleep pretty quickly. Also, i imagine that this would still significantly less painful than all other methods.

 

[bubbletea]

I think even if its a bit painful, it would not last for long as you would fall asleep pretty quickly. Also, i imagine that this would still significantly less painful than all other methods.

Redirect Notice

What do you think about this :(

 

[Jupiter]

Redirect Notice

What do you think about this :(

This is the same case Idorus already posted a link about recently. Have a look what the other two witnesses said.

 

[Jamba]

Redirect Notice

What do you think about this :(

Awful :( However, I would still take that circumstance over all other methods. Being in pain for 3-4minutes over hanging/shooting myself

 

[bubbletea]

This is the same case Idorus already posted a link about recently. Have a look what the other two witnesses said.

Sorry is there a link for what the other witnesses said?

 

[Jupiter]

Here's the full story. Including her unbearable suffering for two years from a brain tumor and the totally different statement of the other two witnesses:

Dealing in the desire for death

A Swiss clinic specialising in assisted suicides has been accused of being too hasty in helping some people die.

www.smh.com.au

 

[ddutch]

These reports are to my view also bit dramatic. Journalism love to that, for the few cases that there was pain out of the 600 they do a good job with providing a exit for people who are ill.

One part goes over the the finance and part about protocol. This can all being viewed from one persons perspective how he or she sees it and than you get this.

 

[fisil]

You just overthinking there is a reason exit and dognitas prefer this method and if something happen it's very rare. A self uses industry N

 

[chrijo]

Redirect Notice

What do you think about this :(

The woman had classic symptoms of a paradoxical reaction on barbiturates. This is very rare but can happen, especially with children and elderly people. This can also happen with benzodiazepines.

 

[GeorgeJL]

Redirect Notice

What do you think about this :(

I think she had a rare allergic reaction to the N.

 

[Jen Erik]

Woman Suffers Painful Death at Zurich Suicide Facility—Investigation May Follow
What do you think about this :(

That article is from a pro-life, religious website, so be sure to consider the source

 

[bubbletea]

That article is from a pro-life, religious website, so be sure to consider the source

Wow you're right

 

[Jupiter]

That article is from a pro-life, religious website, so be sure to consider the source

I think most media are pro life.

 

[Jen Erik]

I think most media are pro life.

I wasn't referring to "most media". I was referring to that specific website.

 

[Jupiter]

I wasn't referring to "most media". I was referring to that specific website.

I know.