I think there are a great many people who are naive about the struggles of people who are suicidal, especially people like us who have so much difficulty getting methods just to have a peaceful death (I know for me my first attempt I was 6 years old). There are also many people who have been suicidal or depressed and recovered, and they think their experiences apply to everyone when that's simply not true. I have empathy for people who are anti-choice suicide. I used to be myself. I think they also believe that pro-choice suicide is just pro-suicide, when pro-choice suicide is wanting people to have dignity and choice in their death, not encouragement of their desires outright. Personally, I will always advocate for alternatives first knowing there are so many people who have been suicidal and/or attempted and were able to move on and are happy now. Good for them. That and people who are only situationally suicidal, like someone who is homeless, disabled, stuck in an abusive situation, etc, who would be ok if they actually had the resources to be able to live and escape their situation. In that case, it's better to direct resources to being able to help them instead of provide them death, when most likely, they don't truly want to die, only escape an avoidable suffering. But I will also always advocate for the choice to die to exist as a last resort. I know that it's what I want for myself, as it's been my whole life and I've never been able to overcome this.